51 Jay St
51 Jay St, Brooklyn, NY, 11201
Year Built
1905
# Stories
6
# Total Units
111
Unit Size Range
664-3,473 sqft
Unit Demand
Low
Unit Availability
Low
About 51 Jay St
51 Jay is a six-story condominium building originally constructed in 1905. It features a selection of units with configurations ranging from 1 to 4 bedrooms, offering diverse living options. The building is distinguished by its historic facade, marrying early 20th-century architectural elements with modern design enhancements. Amenities available to residents include a state-of-the-art fitness center, ideal for maintaining an active lifestyle. The building also boasts a spacious rooftop terrace that provides a relaxing outdoor space. Residents have access to a lounge area, perfect for relaxation or social gatherings. Located at 51 Jay St, Brooklyn, NY, 11201, this development offers proximity to urban amenities. The surrounding area provides various shopping and dining opportunities, contributing to a convenient lifestyle for inhabitants. Unit prices typically range from $5,995,000 to $5,775,000, reflecting the premium nature and desirable features of the property. 51 Jay combines historical charm with contemporary conveniences, making it a notable option for those seeking luxury living in an urban environment. Its position within Brooklyn allows easy access to numerous city attractions, further enhancing the building’s appeal.
Amenities
While the specific amenities are not detailed, imagining what could be at 51 Jay is easy. Picture inviting common areas, perhaps a rooftop terrace with skyline views, or cozy nooks for residents to unwind. The building policies are quite friendly, allowing both cats and dogs, so you won't have to leave your furry friends behind when you move in. It's the kind of place where you can settle in comfortably with your whole family, including the four-legged ones!
Parking
Locker
Concierge
Elevator
Central AC
Pool
Fitness Center-
Visitors ParkingBuilding Policies
Moving into a new home comes with rules meant to enhance everyone’s living experience. At 51 Jay, you’ll be glad to know pets are welcome, as long as you have a cat or dog. This philosophy aligns perfectly with the community spirit you’ll find here—everyone deserves a place to feel at home.
Pets Allowed
Short-term Rental Allowed
BBQ Permitted
Sublet AllowedLoading...
51 Jay St Market Report (last 12 months)
Avg. List Price
$2,577,200 ($1500/Sqft.)
Year-Over-Year List Price
3.66%Total Listings
5Avg. Days On Market
198Avg. Sale Price
$1,491,334 ($1368/Sqft.)
Year-Over-Year Sale Price
44.25%Total Sold
3Avg. HOA Fees/Sqft
$1 /monthly
51 Jay St Sales History
| Unit | Size (sqft) | Beds | Baths | Days On Market | Date | Status | Price | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
 | PHE | 3016 | 4 | 5 | 177 | 2021-11-03 MLS#: RLS10717081 | Closed | $5,500,887 |
 | PHB | 2973 | 4 | 5 | 427 | 2017-08-07 MLS#: RLS10062767 | Closed | $5,995,000 |
| PHE | 3016 | 4 | 5 | 811 | 2017-08-07 MLS#: RLS10061347 | Closed | $5,775,000 |
PHB
4 Beds
5 Baths
2973 sqft
Days On Market427
| Date | Status | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2017-08-07 | Closed | $5,995,000 |
MLS#: RLS10062767
PHE
4 Beds
5 Baths
3016 sqft
Days On Market177
| Date | Status | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2021-11-03 | Closed | $5,500,887 |
MLS#: RLS10717081
PHE
4 Beds
5 Baths
3016 sqft
Days On Market811
| Date | Status | Price |
|---|---|---|
| 2017-08-07 | Closed | $5,775,000 |
MLS#: RLS10061347
View Complete Unit Listing HistorySource By: REBNY
Compare with Buildings in the Neighbourhood (Last 12 Months)
Compare building's average price/sq. ft. and HOA fees/sq. ft. to buildings nearby
| Building Name | Avg price per square foot | AVG HOA FEE per square foot (Monthly) |
|---|---|---|
| 51 Jay St | $1,368/sqft. | $1 /sqft. |
| 168 Plymouth St | $1,550/sqft. | $1 /sqft. |
| 100 Jay St | $1,240/sqft. | $2 /sqft. |
| 37 Bridge St | $1,309/sqft. | $2 /sqft. |
| 1 John St | $2,092/sqft. | $1 /sqft. |
| 133 Water St | $1,139/sqft. | $1 /sqft. |
Nearby Schools
Discover top-rated schools located close to 51 Jay St.
Edmund W Gordon Brooklyn Laboratory Charter School
B+Public|Grades 6–10
77 Sands St|0.28 miles away
P.S. 307 Daniel Hale Williams School
C-Public|Grades PK–5
209 York St|0.38 miles away
Dock Street School for Steam Studies
BPublic|Grades 6–8
19 Dock St|0.4 miles away
P.S. 8 Robert Fulton School
A-Public|Grades KG–8
37 Hicks St|0.5 miles away
Science Skills Center High School for Science, Technology and the Creative Arts
BPublic|Grades 9–12
49 Flatbush Avenue...|0.56 miles away
Brooklyn International High School
D+Public|Grades 9–12
49 Flatbush Avenue...|0.56 miles away
Schools
View nearby schools
View nearby schools
Schools
Edmund W Gordon Brooklyn Laboratory Charter School
B+Public|Grades 6–10
77 Sands St|Less than 1 Mile Away
P.S. 307 Daniel Hale Williams School
C-Public|Grades PK–5
209 York St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Dock Street School for Steam Studies
BPublic|Grades 6–8
19 Dock St|Less than 1 Mile Away
P.S. 8 Robert Fulton School
A-Public|Grades KG–8
37 Hicks St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Science Skills Center High School for Science, Technology and the Creative Arts
BPublic|Grades 9–12
49 Flatbush Avenue...|Less than 1 Mile Away
Brooklyn International High School
D+Public|Grades 9–12
49 Flatbush Avenue...|Less than 1 Mile Away
The Urban Assembly School of Music and Art at Waters Edge
D+Public|Grades 9–12
49 Flatbush Avenue...|Less than 1 Mile Away
Brooklyn Laboratory Charter School
C+Public|Grades 6–12
240 Jay St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Plymouth Church School
--Private|Grades PK–KG
75 Hicks St|Less than 1 Mile Away
P.S. 287 Bailey K. Ashford School
DPublic|Grades KG–6
50 Navy St|Less than 1 Mile Away
PS 184 Shuang Wen
A+Public|Grades PK–8
327 Cherry St Fl S...|Less than 1 Mile Away
City Polytechnic High School of Engineering, Architecture and Technology
C+Public|Grades 9–12
105 Tech Pl|Less than 1 Mile Away
Intermediate School 915
--Public|Grades 6–8
105 Tech Pl|Less than 1 Mile Away
George Westinghouse Career and Technical Education High School
D+Public|Grades 9–12
105 Tech Pl|Less than 1 Mile Away
Urban Assembly Institute of Math and Science for Young Women
BPublic|Grades 6–12
283 Adams St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Urban Assembly School for Law and Justice (The)
CPublic|Grades 9–12
283 Adams St|Less than 1 Mile Away
University Neighborhood High School
B-Public|Grades 9–12
200 Monroe St|Less than 1 Mile Away
St Ann's School
--Private|Grades PK–12
129 Pierrepont St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Orchard Collegiate Academy
C+Public|Grades 9–12
220 Henry St|Less than 1 Mile Away
University Neighborhood Middle School
DPublic|Grades 6–8
220 Henry St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Manhattan Charter School II
C+Public|Grades KG–5
220 Henry St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Dr Susan S Mckinney Secondary School of the Arts
C-Public|Grades 6–12
101 Park Ave|Less than 1 Mile Away
Success Academy Charter School-Fort Greene
A-Public|Grades KG–4
101 Park Ave Fl AV...|Less than 1 Mile Away
Fusion Academy Brk: Brooklyn
--Private|Grades 6–12
1 Metrotech Ctr N ...|Less than 1 Mile Away
P.S. 2 Meyer London School
BPublic|Grades KG–5
122 Henry St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Community Roots Charter School
BPublic|Grades KG–8
51 Saint Edwards S...|Less than 1 Mile Away
P.S. 67 Charles A. Dorsey School
D+Public|Grades PK–5
51 Saint Edwards S...|Less than 1 Mile Away
P.S. 126 Jacob August Riis School
A+Public|Grades PK–8
80 Catherine St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Brooklyn Friends School
--Private|Grades PK–12
375 Pearl St|Less than 1 Mile Away
Mesivta Tifereth Jerusalem
--Private|Grades KG–12
145 E Broadway|1.00 Miles Away
Brooklyn Autism Center Academy
--Private|Grades KG–KG
120 Lawrence St|1.01 Miles Away
Altschool
--Private|Grades KG–5
212 Hicks St|1.01 Miles Away
International Charter School of New York (The)
CPublic|Grades KG–5
47 Willoughby St #...|1.01 Miles Away
PS 134 Henrietta Szold
D+Public|Grades PK–5
293 E Broadway|1.02 Miles Away
Brooklyn Prospect Charter School-Csd 13
B+Public|Grades KG–8
80 Willoughby St|1.04 Miles Away
P.S. 1 Alfred E. Smith School
C-Public|Grades KG–5
8 Henry St|1.13 Miles Away
Greene Hill School
--Private|Grades PK–8
39 Adelphi St|1.14 Miles Away
P.S. 124 Yung Wing School
A+Public|Grades PK–5
40 Division St|1.17 Miles Away
PS 110 Florence Nightingale
A-Public|Grades PK–5
285 Delancey St|1.17 Miles Away
The Peck Slip School
A+Public|Grades PK–5
1 Peck Slip|1.17 Miles Away
Blue School
--Private|Grades PK–8
241 Water St|1.18 Miles Away
P.S. 42 Benjamin Altman School
A+Public|Grades PK–5
71 Hester St|1.20 Miles Away
Beth Jacob Parochial School
--Private|Grades PK–8
142 Broome St|1.21 Miles Away
Brooklyn Frontiers High School
D-Public|Grades 9–12
112 Schermerhorn S...|1.24 Miles Away
A Fantis Parochial School
--Private|Grades PK–8
195 State St|1.25 Miles Away
Murry Bergtraum High School for Business Careers
D+Public|Grades 9–12
411 Pearl St|1.26 Miles Away
Manhattan Early College School for Advertising
CPublic|Grades 9–12
411 Pearl St|1.27 Miles Away
Urban Assembly Maker Academy
C-Public|Grades 9–12
411 Pearl St|1.27 Miles Away
Urban Assembly School for Emergency Management (The)
D+Public|Grades 9–12
411 Pearl St|1.27 Miles Away
Pace High School
D+Public|Grades 9–12
100 Hester St|1.28 Miles Away
Transit
Experience convenience and connectivity with premium transit options just moments away.
3 AV/STATE ST
1.66 miles away|32 min walk
3 AV/DEAN ST
1.81 miles away|35 min walk
1 AV/E 1 ST
1.83 miles away|36 min walk
2 Av
1.84 miles away|36 min walk
4 AV/PACIFIC ST
1.88 miles away|36 min walk
4 AV/DEAN ST
1.89 miles away|37 min walk
Transit
View nearby transit options
View nearby transit options
Transit
3 AV/STATE ST
1.66 miles away|32 min walk
3 AV/DEAN ST
1.81 miles away|35 min walk
1 AV/E 1 ST
1.83 miles away|36 min walk
2 Av
1.84 miles away|36 min walk
4 AV/PACIFIC ST
1.88 miles away|36 min walk
4 AV/DEAN ST
1.89 miles away|37 min walk
6 AV/WHITE ST
1.94 miles away|38 min walk
3 AV/WARREN ST
1.97 miles away|38 min walk
3 AV/BALTIC ST
1.99 miles away|39 min walk
1 AV /E 4 ST
2.01 miles away|39 min walk
2 AV/E 3 ST
2.02 miles away|39 min walk
6 AV/WEST BROADWAY
2.05 miles away|40 min walk
6 AV/W BROADWAY
2.05 miles away|40 min walk
4 AV/WARREN ST
2.08 miles away|40 min walk
5 AV/DEAN ST
2.08 miles away|40 min walk
5 AV/BERGEN ST
2.08 miles away|40 min walk
3 AV/BUTLER ST
2.09 miles away|40 min walk
3 AV/DOUGLASS ST
2.13 miles away|41 min walk
2 AV/E 6 ST
2.17 miles away|42 min walk
5 AV/PROSPECT PL
2.18 miles away|42 min walk
6 AV/GRAND ST
2.19 miles away|42 min walk
3 AV/DEGRAW ST
2.2 miles away|43 min walk
5 AV/WARREN ST
2.22 miles away|43 min walk
1 AV/SAINT MARKS PL
2.23 miles away|43 min walk
3 AV/UNION ST
2.27 miles away|44 min walk
6 AV/BROOME ST
2.27 miles away|44 min walk
5 AV/SAINT JOHNS PL
2.32 miles away|45 min walk
2 AV/E 9 ST
2.32 miles away|45 min walk
6 AV/SPRING ST
2.36 miles away|46 min walk
5 AV/DOUGLASS ST
2.37 miles away|46 min walk
3 AV/CARROLL ST
2.38 miles away|46 min walk
1 AV/E 11 ST
2.4 miles away|46 min walk
6 AV/PRINCE ST
2.45 miles away|47 min walk
3 AV/E 9 ST
2.47 miles away|48 min walk
5 AV/UNION ST
2.48 miles away|48 min walk
8 St-NYU
2.49 miles away|48 min walk
2 AV/E 12 ST
2.5 miles away|48 min walk
7 AV/FLATBUSH AV
2.51 miles away|49 min walk
3 AV/E 11 ST
2.52 miles away|49 min walk
4 AV/E 9 ST
2.53 miles away|49 min walk
1 Av
2.53 miles away|49 min walk
7 AV/STERLING PL
2.55 miles away|49 min walk
6 AV/WEST HOUSTON ST
2.56 miles away|50 min walk
4 AV/E 10 ST
2.56 miles away|50 min walk
3 AV/3 ST
2.56 miles away|50 min walk
2 AV/E 13 ST
2.59 miles away|50 min walk
7 Av
2.6 miles away|50 min walk
5 AV/GARFIELD PL
2.63 miles away|51 min walk
1 AV/E 14 ST
2.64 miles away|51 min walk
1 AV/E 15 ST
2.64 miles away|51 min walk
The Neighborhood:
Get the HelloCondo Newsletter
Real-estate tips, insights, and market reports in your inbox.
Nearby Cities
Buildings
Neighborhoods
ZIP Codes
Community
10 East 43rd Street104 Bedford Street130 Jane Street
145 West 12th Street173 Riverside Drive190 72nd Street20-40 89th Street226 East 12th Street2705 Kings Highway30 West 60th Street308 West 97th Street32-23 90th Street33-15 81st Street33-52 81st Street34-30 78th Street35-11 85th Street350 West 56th Street39 Gramercy Park North43-33 46th Street438 12th Street
HelloCondo Is The #1 Condo Search Platform And Real Estate Recommendation Engine. Search, Find And Buy The Perfect Condo And Get Matched With The Best Agents. Finding A Condo Has Never Been So Easy.
HelloCondo is a division of HelloCasa, LLC
HelloCondo
Find A RealtorTerms of UsePrivacy PolicyCalifornia Privacy NoticeAccessibility PolicyCCPA Notice on CollectionDMCABrowseNYS Standard Operating ProcedureNYS Fair Housing NoticeContact
300 Galleria Pkwy SE, Suite 1500,
Atlanta, GA 30339
Atlanta, GA 30339
(855) 625-0319
Century21, Awaye Realty
Arlene Waye
526 Court Street
Brooklyn, NY 11231
(718) 488-0800
© HelloCondo 2025. All Rights Reserved.